What is best execution?
Best execution means that a financial service provider executes its clients' orders so that the client obtains the best possible outcome. In Switzerland, the duty is set out in Art. 18 FinSA: the best possible outcome is measured in terms of cost, timing and quality. The Financial Services Ordinance specifies it, and the order-handling duty in Art. 17 FinSA complements it.
This article covers the Swiss rules for independent portfolio managers and their compliance officers. Best execution under MiFID II in the EU and under US FINRA rules follows separate frameworks and is outside the scope of this article. The other FinSA rules of conduct are brought together in our FinSA knowledge hub.
Art. 18 FinSA: the duty for portfolio managers
Portfolio management is a financial service within the meaning of Art. 3 let. c FinSA (item 3). Anyone who provides financial services on a commercial basis is a financial service provider (Art. 3 let. d FinSA). Under Art. 17(1) FinIA, a portfolio manager is a person mandated to manage assets on a commercial basis in the name of and on behalf of clients. Portfolio managers are therefore bound by the FinSA rules of conduct, including Art. 18 FinSA.
The provision contains three elements:
- Best possible outcome: in the execution of client orders, the provider ensures the best possible outcome in terms of cost, timing and quality (para. 1).
- Total cost: cost covers the price of the financial instrument, the expenses incurred in executing the order and the compensation from third parties within the meaning of Art. 26(3) FinSA (para. 2). How such compensation is disclosed and passed on is explained in our article on retrocessions for portfolio managers.
- Internal directives: a provider that employs staff to execute client orders issues internal directives on order execution, commensurate with the number of such staff and the structure of operations (para. 3).
The client segment determines the scope. Under Art. 20 FinSA, the rules of conduct do not apply to transactions with institutional clients (para. 1). Professional clients may expressly release the provider only from the duties of information under Art. 8 FinSA and Art. 9 FinSA, documentation under Art. 15 FinSA and rendering of account under Art. 16 FinSA (para. 2); best execution is not among them and applies to them in full. How the segments are assigned is described in our article on FinSA client segmentation.
Which factors count: price, costs, speed, likelihood of execution
Art. 21 FinSO translates the duty into four requirements:
- The provider defines the criteria for selecting the place of execution, in particular the price, costs, speed and likelihood of execution and settlement (para. 1).
- Where the client has issued an express directive, the order is executed accordingly (para. 2).
- At the client's request, the provider furnishes proof that it executed the client's orders in accordance with these criteria (para. 3).
- The provider reviews the effectiveness of the criteria at least once a year (para. 4).
The ordinance names the criteria without ranking them. Their weighting is therefore a decision of the portfolio manager, recorded in its policy; a policy may, for example, weight price and costs more heavily for liquid listed shares and the likelihood of execution and settlement more heavily for less liquid instruments.
Handling client orders fairly
Art. 17 FinSA requires good faith and equal treatment when handling client orders, and Art. 20 FinSO requires processes and systems appropriate to the provider's size, complexity and business activity that ensure in particular that:
- client orders are registered and allocated immediately and correctly,
- comparable client orders are executed immediately in the sequence received, subject to the nature of the order, market conditions and the client's interest,
- when orders are pooled and trades allocated, the interests of the clients concerned are safeguarded,
- retail clients are informed immediately of any material difficulties that could impair the correct execution of the order.
Best execution when orders go through the custodian bank
A portfolio manager may transmit its orders to the client's custodian bank, which executes them. Art. 18 FinSA and Art. 21 FinSO refer to the execution of client orders and contain no separate rule for orders that a provider transmits to a bank for execution. A portfolio manager working in this set-up sets out in its policy how it applies the execution criteria:
- Choice of custodian bank: which banks the portfolio manager works with, whether the client chose the bank, and which express client directives on execution exist; these are followed under Art. 21(2) FinSO and documented.
- Execution arrangements of the bank: the bank's information on how it executes orders, assessed against the portfolio manager's own criteria.
- Order routing: which order types and instrument classes are placed with which bank and how.
- Costs: the fees and third-party compensation that make up the total cost under Art. 18(2) FinSA.
Best execution policy: what it should contain
The best execution policy serves as the internal directive on order execution under Art. 18(3) FinSA and forms part of the internal regulations through which a provider fulfils its duties under Art. 21 FinSA. For a portfolio manager, it covers:
- Scope: services, client segments and instrument classes covered; treatment of institutional clients.
- Execution criteria: price, costs, speed, likelihood of execution and settlement, with their weighting per instrument class.
- Custodian banks and execution venues: banks used, basis for their selection and how their execution arrangements are assessed.
- Client directives: how express directives are recorded and followed.
- Order handling: registration, sequence, time stamps, aggregation and allocation of block orders, information to retail clients on difficulties.
- Costs and third-party compensation: which cost elements are considered and how compensation from third parties is treated.
- Monitoring and review: controls during the year and the annual review of effectiveness.
- Proof to clients: procedure for furnishing proof on request.
- Responsibilities: who executes, who controls, who approves the policy and its changes.
- Training: instruction of staff who handle orders.
Monitoring and annual review
The annual review under Art. 21(4) FinSO checks the effectiveness of the criteria, measured against the best possible outcome for the client that Art. 21(1) FinSO aims at. Art. 23 FinSO adds that, where a business unit consists of several persons, the provider ensures effective monitoring, in particular by means of appropriate internal controls, and defines binding work and business processes. A practical review covers:
- a sample of executed orders compared with market prices at the time of the order,
- the costs charged per bank and instrument class,
- the time between the investment decision, the order and its execution,
- the allocation of aggregated orders,
- client complaints and execution errors,
- changes at the custodian banks or in the instrument universe.
The findings, the resulting changes to the criteria and the approval belong in a short, dated review report.
Documentation and audit evidence
Under Art. 15 FinSA, the provider documents the financial services provided for clients. Rendering of account covers the documentation on the orders received and executed (Art. 19(1)(a) FinSO), and the documentation is structured so that account can, as a rule, be rendered within ten working days (Art. 18 FinSO). Together with the duty of proof under Art. 21(3) FinSO and the organisational duties under Art. 23 FinSO, these provisions point to the following evidence, which the portfolio manager should keep ready for the audit:
- the approved and dated best execution policy,
- the order journal with time stamps and allocations,
- records of express client directives,
- the annual review reports with approvals,
- proof furnished to clients on request,
- training records of staff handling orders.
FINMA Circular 2025/2 specifies information duties, the appropriateness and suitability assessment, securities lending, conflicts of interest and retrocessions (margin nos. 4–30); Arts. 17 and 18 FinSA are not among its legal bases, so best execution follows directly from the Act and the Ordinance. The Circular is summarised in our article on FINMA Circular 2025/2. What the supervisory organisations look at in their FinSA audits, including transparency in client orders, is set out in our article on the FinSA audit 2026. Whether the instruments themselves fit the client is covered in our article on the suitability and appropriateness assessment.
Step by step to best execution
- 1Define the scopeservices, client segments and instrument classes.
- 2Set the criteriaweight the four factors per instrument class.
- 3Map the custodian banksrecord client directives and assess each bank's execution arrangements.
- 4Write and approve the policyorder handling, allocation, proof to clients, responsibilities.
- ✓Monitor and reviewrun the controls and the annual review; adjust the criteria and document the result.
Checklist
- Policy approved, dated and known to staff handling orders
- Criteria weighted per instrument class
- Client directives documented
- Allocation rule for block orders in place
- Annual review report on file
How Peak Compliance supports you
Peak Compliance drafts best execution policies, embeds the annual review in the control plan and prepares the evidence for the FinSA audit as part of compliance outsourcing. For a conversation, you can reach us via the contact page.



