What it is about
Anyone who manages assets or gives investment advice checks, before every service, whether it fits the client. The Financial Services Act (FinSA) provides two assessments for this: the suitability assessment and the appropriateness assessment. Under Art. 10 FinSA, every financial service provider that provides investment advice or portfolio management performs one or the other.
This article is a guide for independent portfolio managers and their compliance officers: which assessment applies when, what is collected from the client, what applies to professional and institutional clients, how to proceed where information is incomplete, how the assessment is documented and what the supervisors look at. The other rules of conduct are brought together in our FinSA knowledge hub.
Which assessment applies to which service?
What counts is the type of financial service within the meaning of Art. 3 let. c FinSA, not the product.
| Service | Assessment | Information collected | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Portfolio management | Suitability assessment | financial situation, investment objectives, knowledge and experience – relating to the service | Art. 12 FinSA |
| Investment advice taking account of the client portfolio (portfolio-related) | Suitability assessment | as for portfolio management | Art. 12 FinSA |
| Investment advice for individual transactions, without the entire portfolio (transaction-related) | Appropriateness assessment | knowledge and experience | Art. 11 FinSA |
| Solely executing or transmitting client orders | no assessment | – ; notice to the client before the service that no assessment is performed | Art. 13(1) and (2) FinSA |
For portfolio managers, this means: the portfolio management mandate triggers the suitability assessment. Where the portfolio manager also offers advice or execution only, it assigns each client relationship to one row of the table. FINMA Circular 2025/2 requires the type of investment advice – transaction-related or portfolio-related – to be identified and documented vis-à-vis the client, for example in the contract or by a documented statement at the time of the advice (margin no. 4).
What does the portfolio manager collect from the client?
The suitability assessment rests on three groups of information; Art. 17 FinSO specifies the first two:
- Financial situation: nature and amount of regular income, assets, and current and future financial obligations (para. 1).
- Investment objectives: in particular the time horizon and purpose of the investment, willingness to take risks and any investment restrictions (para. 2).
- Knowledge and experience: for the suitability assessment, relating to the financial service, not to the individual transactions (Art. 12 FinSA). Circular 2025/2 requires the enquiry for each relevant investment category; for portfolio management, taking into account the investment strategy and the types of financial instruments used. The questions are as detailed as the complexity and risk profile of the investments require (margin no. 14).
Based on this information, the portfolio manager draws up a risk profile for every client and, for portfolio management mandates and continuing advisory relationships, agrees an investment strategy (Art. 17(3) FinSO). For the risk profile, it enquires about all the information it needs to perform the assessment properly (margin no. 13). It may rely on the information given by the client unless there are indications that it is incorrect (Art. 17(4) FinSO).
Where the client acts through an authorised person, that person's knowledge and experience count for both assessments (Art. 16 FinSO).
Suitability during the mandate
The suitability assessment does not end with the risk profile. In FINMA Guidance 03/2026, FINMA states that the financial instruments used must be suitable, taking into account the risk profile and the agreed investment strategy; with high-risk, complex or illiquid instruments in the portfolios of retail clients, the assessment deserves particular attention (section 3.1). What this means for product selection is described in our article on FINMA Guidance 03/2026 and product risks.
Where risk concentrations that are unusual for the market cannot be ruled out in the portfolio, the portfolio manager also informs the client about the nature and extent of the concentration risks; as indications, Circular 2025/2 cites concentrations of 10% or more in single securities and 20% or more with single issuers (margin nos. 9–11).
What applies to professional and institutional clients?
The scope of the assessment depends on the client segment under Art. 4 FinSA; how segments, opting out and opting in work is explained in our article on FinSA client segmentation.
- Retail clients: full suitability or appropriateness assessment. This also applies to professional clients who have opted in under Art. 5 FinSA.
- Professional clients: the assessment remains, with one relief. The portfolio manager may assume that professional clients have the required knowledge and experience and can financially bear the investment risks (Art. 13(3) FinSA). This provision does not mention the investment objectives. Under Art. 20(2) FinSA, professional clients may release the provider only from the duties of information, documentation and rendering of account, not from the assessment; the release is given in writing or in another form demonstrable via text, in a document separate from the general terms and conditions (Art. 22 FinSO).
- Institutional clients: for transactions with them, the rules of conduct in Arts. 7–20 FinSA do not apply (Art. 20(1) FinSA) – nor does the duty to review.
What applies when information is incomplete or suitability is lacking?
Art. 14 FinSA covers three cases:
- Information is insufficient: the portfolio manager informs the client before providing the service that it cannot assess suitability or appropriateness (para. 1).
- Instrument is not suitable or appropriate: it advises the client against it before providing the service (para. 2).
- Knowledge and experience are lacking: providing the client with information can compensate for this (para. 3).
The advice against belongs in the documentation, as does the notice in the case of execution only (Art. 15(1)(b) FinSA). A provider that informs clients only once that no assessment is performed in the case of execution only must expressly point this out in that notice (Art. 17(5) FinSO).
How is the assessment documented?
Under Art. 15 FinSA, the portfolio manager documents in an appropriate manner:
- the financial services agreed and the information collected about the client,
- the notice under Art. 13(2) FinSA or the advice against under Art. 14 FinSA,
- the financial services provided,
- for investment advice, also the client's needs and the grounds for each recommendation leading to an acquisition or disposal (para. 2).
The documentation is structured so that the portfolio manager can, as a rule, render account within ten working days (Art. 18 FinSO). On request, the client receives a copy and an account of the services agreed and provided, of the composition, valuation and development of the portfolio and of the costs (Art. 16 FinSA); account is rendered on a durable data medium, at the agreed intervals and on request (Art. 19 FinSO).
What do the supervisors look at?
- Circular 2025/2: it is addressed to financial service providers supervised by FINMA or by a supervisory organisation (margin no. 2), names portfolio managers among its addressees and has applied since 1 January 2025. The transitional period until 30 June 2025 applied only to certain margin numbers, not to the appropriateness and suitability assessment (margin nos. 13–14 and 31).
- Supervisory organisations: AOOS supervision covers FinSA; its audit programmes are generally separate for AMLA, FinIA and FinSA (AOOS directive on supervision and control, basic principles and audit programmes). OSFINcontrol expects a directive on dealing with clients that governs the client profile, the appropriateness and suitability assessment and documentation, and reviews it at the affiliation audit and in ongoing supervision; the line manager and the person responsible for risk and compliance are to review the documentation regularly (information sheet on dealing with clients, version of 15 April 2021).
- FINMA: in the cases concerning portfolio managers escalated to it, irregularities were particularly serious where complex, high-risk or illiquid products were used without an adequate suitability assessment, without regard to risk capacity and risk appetite and without risk disclosure (Guidance 03/2026, section 2).
The topics the supervisory organisations look at in their FinSA audits overall are set out in our article on the FinSA audit 2026; the content of the Circular is summarised in our article on FINMA Circular 2025/2.
Step by step to a sound assessment
- 1Define the servicefor each client relationship, determine whether it is portfolio management, portfolio-related or transaction-related advice, or execution only, and identify this in the contract.
- 2Assign the segmentrecord and evidence the client segment; record opting out and opting in in writing or in another form demonstrable via text.
- 3Collect the informationcapture financial situation, investment objectives, and knowledge and experience for each relevant investment category with a questionnaire whose depth matches the strategies offered.
- 4Risk profile and strategyderive the risk profile and agree the investment strategy with the client.
- 5Review suitability on an ongoing basischeck new financial instruments against the risk profile and strategy and disclose concentration risks; update the information when the client's circumstances change materially.
- ✓Document and controlrecord notices, advice against and the grounds for recommendations, and review client files by sampling within the internal control system; the ongoing control function is described on our Risk Management Outsourcing page.
Checklist
- Type of service identified and documented for each client relationship
- Questionnaire covers financial situation, investment objectives, and knowledge and experience per investment category
- Risk profile and agreed investment strategy in place for every mandate
- Knowledge and experience of authorised persons recorded
- Procedure for incomplete information and lacking suitability set out in the directive
- Notice for execution only express and documented
- Releases by professional clients in a separate document
- Documentation allows account to be rendered, as a rule, within ten working days
- Sampling of client files in the control plan
How Peak Compliance supports you
Peak Compliance embeds the suitability and appropriateness assessment in directives, client questionnaires and controls and reviews them on an ongoing basis as part of compliance outsourcing. For a conversation, you can reach us via the contact page.



