What it is about
Retrocessions are payments that a portfolio manager receives from third parties – for example from the custodian bank out of the fees it charges the client, or from providers of funds and structured products as a distribution fee or trailer fee. For portfolio managers under Art. 17(1) FinIA, four questions arise: who the money belongs to, when it may be kept, what is disclosed, and how this is evidenced to the audit firm and the supervisory organisation.
The other rules of conduct are brought together in the FinSA knowledge hub. How remuneration flows back in structured solutions is shown in the article on the key risks of Actively Managed Certificates.
Who do retrocessions belong to?
Two sets of rules apply side by side:
- Law of mandate: The portfolio management contract is governed by the rules on mandates. The mandatee returns anything received for whatever reason as a result of the activities under the mandate (Art. 400(1) CO). Retrocessions – and finder's fees where the custodian bank was recommended – fall under this rule because they accrue in connection with the management of the assets; the mandatee may keep only what it receives merely on the occasion of the mandate (BGE 132 III 460 consid. 4.1).
- Regulatory law: Financial service providers accept compensation from third parties only if they have expressly informed the clients in advance and the clients relinquish it, or if they pass the compensation on to the clients in full (Art. 26(1) FinSA). Compensation includes in particular brokerage fees, commissions, discounts or other financial benefits (Art. 26(3) FinSA).
The label does not matter. Trailer fees from product providers are also to be returned in portfolio management (case: a bank as portfolio manager), because they create the risk that the manager does not sufficiently safeguard the client's interests (BGE 138 III 755 consid. 5.4–5.6); this also applies to payments from companies of the manager's own group (consid. 8.4). Under regulatory law, group companies are expressly deemed to be third parties (Art. 29(2) FinSO). In January 2026, the Federal Supreme Court confirmed in the case of a bank (execution only): because the portfolio manager itself determines which transactions it carries out and how often, payments from the custodian bank and trailer fees are in inner connection with the mandate and are to be returned (BGE 152 III 240 consid. 3.5.3).
When is a waiver valid?
The duty to return is not mandatory. The client can waive payments already received after the fact, or future payments in advance (BGE 137 III 393 consid. 2.2). An advance waiver holds under these conditions:
| Condition | What it means | Reference |
|---|---|---|
| Complete and truthful information and a clear intention to waive | The intention to waive delivery emerges clearly from the agreement; industry practice or silence do not replace it | BGE 132 III 460 consid. 4.2–4.5 |
| Key parameters of the agreements with third parties | The client knows the calculation bases of the payments of each custodian bank and each product provider | BGE 137 III 393 consid. 2.4 |
| Order of magnitude in per cent of the assets under management | Only this allows the retrocessions to be compared with the fee; this also applies to funds and structured products | BGE 137 III 393 consid. 2.4; BGE 138 III 755 consid. 6.3 |
| Specific information instead of general statements | The sentence that any retrocessions belong to the manager, or the maximum possible amount, is not sufficient | BGE 137 III 393 consid. 2.6; BGE 138 III 755 consid. 6.3 |
For an external asset manager, a range of 0 to 1 % «of the invested volume» was not sufficient because it allowed no comparison with the fee; the Federal Supreme Court denied a valid waiver (judgment 4A_355/2019 consid. 3.2–3.4).
Three points shape practice:
- Information is a precondition: The client cannot waive the information itself in advance; that would amount to a waiver of the return without any precondition (BGE 137 III 393 consid. 2.4).
- Explanation according to experience: An inexperienced person is informed about all points and connections; for a knowledgeable person, the technical key parameters and the percentage range are sufficient (consid. 2.5).
- Burden of proof on the manager: Whoever relies on the waiver proves that the client was sufficiently informed (consid. 2.5).
What does Art. 26 FinSA require for disclosure?
The information states the type and scope of the compensation and is given before the financial service is provided or before the contract is concluded. If the amount cannot be determined in advance, the financial service provider informs the clients of the calculation parameters and the ranges; upon request, it discloses the amounts effectively received (Art. 26(2) FinSA). FINMA specifies this in FINMA Circular 2025/2, which is also addressed to financial service providers supervised by a supervisory organisation (margin no. 2):
- In standard-form contracts, the information on compensation is to be visually highlighted; it is physically available or easy to find electronically (margin no. 26).
- Where the amount is unknown, the portfolio manager states ranges per class of financial instruments and, in addition, ranges based on the portfolio value and the agreed investment strategy (margin nos. 27–29).
- It discloses the amounts effectively received upon request, in principle free of charge (margin no. 30).
What the circular regulates on the other duties of conduct is summarised in the article on Circular 2025/2 and the duties of conduct under FinSA.
The rules on conflicts of interest come on top: the portfolio manager provides information on business affiliations with third parties (Art. 8(2)(b) FinSA), takes organisational precautions and discloses any remaining disadvantage (Art. 25 FinSA). It discloses compensation from third parties in association with the provision of financial services that by its very nature cannot be passed on as a conflict of interest (Art. 29(1) FinSO), and it documents for which services conflicts of interest may arise (Art. 28 FinSO).
Meeting both standards at once: According to the Dispatch, which the Federal Supreme Court cites, Art. 26 FinSA is a regulatory duty to inform and to pass on; it does not take precedence over the claims under the law of mandate, but civil courts may draw on it to give them concrete shape (BGE 152 III 240 consid. 3.6.5.2). Information and waiver are therefore designed to satisfy both the case law (percentage range of the assets under management) and the circular (ranges per class, by portfolio value and investment strategy).
Annual statement: Beyond disclosing the amounts effectively received upon request (Art. 26(2) FinSA), FinSA and FinSO require no statement of retrocessions in the annual statement; the rendering of account at the agreed intervals covers orders, portfolio and costs (Art. 19 FinSO). Disclosure upon request is sufficient, however, only where the portfolio manager keeps the retrocessions under a valid waiver (section «When is a waiver valid?»). Otherwise, it informs the client on its own initiative of the retrocessions actually accruing (BGE 132 III 460 consid. 4.5) and returns them (section «Return, prescription and criminal law»). For assets of pension funds, it is bound under the occupational pensions ordinance BVV 2 to hand over all financial benefits beyond the agreed remuneration and confirms this to the supreme governing body in writing every year. For reasons of transparency, it may show the retrocessions received in the year or the ranges of retrocessions separately in the statement; this does not replace a missing waiver.
Does this also apply to execution only?
For a bank in a pure account and custody relationship, the Federal Supreme Court denied the return under Art. 400(1) CO in the specific case: the bank only executed orders, had no discretion over the assets and was exposed to no conflict of interest (BGE 152 III 240 consid. 3.6–3.7). For the portfolio manager, the duty to return remains, because it decides on the investments itself (consid. 3.5.3). Under regulatory law, Art. 26 FinSA applies according to the Dispatch to every type of financial service, including mere execution (consid. 3.6.5.2).
Return, prescription and criminal law
Where there is no valid waiver, the portfolio manager returns the retrocessions and gives an account of the amounts received (Art. 400(1) CO). The claim for return prescribes after ten years (Art. 127 CO); for each payment, the period begins on the day the mandatee received it, even if the mandator knew nothing about it (case: refunds from insurance premiums; BGE 143 III 348 consid. 5.2–5.5).
Under criminal law, the Federal Supreme Court has held that a portfolio manager who does not inform its clients of retrocessions from the custodian bank can commit criminal mismanagement (Art. 158 no. 1 SCC; BGE 144 IV 294 consid. 3.3). The decisive factor is the duty to account: only this puts the client in a position to demand the return. A waiver clause without prior information on the scope did not help in the case decided (consid. 3.4).
What do supervisors review?
Portfolio managers are subject to ongoing supervision by a supervisory organisation (Art. 61(2) FinIA) and appoint an audit firm to perform an annual audit, whose frequency the supervisory organisation may extend to a maximum of four years (Art. 62 FinIA). Indications of what supervision and audit focus on:
- Directive on conflicts of interest: OSFINcontrol names compensation from third parties – expressly kick-backs and retrocessions – as a conflict of interest that the directive governs, and reviews the directive during the affiliation review and in ongoing supervision (OSFINcontrol, fact sheet on the directive on conflicts of interest). The portfolio manager reviews the directives on conflicts of interest between clients and staff regularly (Art. 25(f) FinSO).
- Implementation of the circular: highlighting in the contract, ranges and disclosure upon request free of charge (margin nos. 26–30); the transitional period for the highlighting ran until 30 June 2025 (margin no. 31).
- Own products: In cases escalated to FINMA, it found among portfolio managers, among other things, non-transparent double fee charging and remuneration incentives favouring the use of their own products (FINMA Guidance 03/2026, section 2). For context, see the article on FINMA Guidance 03/2026.
Step by step
Peak Compliance recommends this sequence; the duties are set out in the sections above.
- 1Record payment flowskeep all agreements with custodian banks, fund providers and issuers, including those within the group, in a register with the calculation basis.
- 2Define the modeldecide for each type of mandate whether compensation is passed on or kept under an informed waiver.
- 3Prepare the informationkey parameters per agreement, ranges in per cent of the assets under management per class of financial instruments and by investment strategy.
- 4Design the contractwaiver expressly stated and visually highlighted, information handed over before the contract is concluded, receipt evidenced for each client.
- 5Settle on an ongoing basisreconcile credits periodically with the register, book the amounts passed on, answer requests for the amounts effectively received free of charge.
- ✓Control and evidenceanchor the control in the internal control system, review the directive regularly, keep the documents ready for the audit firm.
Checklist
- Register of all agreements on compensation from third parties, group companies included
- Ranges in per cent of the assets under management per class of financial instruments and by investment strategy
- Waiver clause expressly worded and visually highlighted
- Evidence for each client that the information was available before the contract was concluded
- Process for passing on compensation where a valid waiver is missing
- Information on the amounts effectively received, free of charge, regulated
- Directive on conflicts of interest with a section on retrocessions, reviewed regularly
- Documentation of conflicts of interest per service
How Peak Compliance supports you
Through compliance outsourcing, Peak Compliance prepares and maintains directives and document templates – such as the directive on conflicts of interest and the information on compensation from third parties – and accompanies the implementation of new requirements from FinSA, circulars and case law. To discuss your compensation model, reach us via the contact page.



